Marillion – Sounds That Can’t Be Made (2012)

Unbelievable, but this is the band’s 17th studio album! Most of their fans are totally and exclusively in love with their debut trilogy of “Script for a Jester’s Tear (1983)”, “Fugazi (1984)”, and “Misplaced Childhood (1985)”, and everything after Fish leaving and “Clutching at Straws (1987)” seems to did not really mattered. And yes, this is kind of unfair, but Marillion after 1988 and with Steve Hogarth as their new singer, was a totally different plate of food – food for spirit, obviously. And yes, as Hogarth fairly noticed in an interview in 2000: “If we had known when I joined Marillion what we know now, we’d have changed the name and been a new band. It was a mistake to keep the name, because what it represented in the mid-Eighties is a millstone we now carry. If we’d changed it, I think we would have been better off. We would have been judged for our music. It’s such a grave injustice that the media constantly calls us a “dinosaur prog band”…”
And Marillion had a few great moments and several good albums in the last two decades, but mainly the media refuse to notice them.

My post Fish era favorite still stays the “ancient” “Afraid of Sunlight” (1995), but Marillion were always a band to listen, to dive into their music. Not always was completely convinced by their choices, but I always find interesting moments on their records.
“Sounds That Can’t Be Made” definitively is one of the most challenging Marillion releases of their “neo progressive” era. The over 17 minutes of the opening “Gaza” are a really soulful journey into different layers and sounds, changing the mood, the vibe of the track, building up a healthy tension and playing well the balance and ontrast of some really dark and heavy riffs against some almost cinematic, spacy soundscapes. It’s almost like an Industrial fueled Led Zeppelin in some of its most explosive moments! A much sensitive take is “Power”, but really a great build-up are the over 14 minutes of “Montr©al”. This one have something from the old Marillion’s rage and energy, but definitively in a more bitter, more mature and cynical manner expressed. While Fish was always 100% involved, submerged, Steve Hogarth often seems to be more a story teller, a wise man from the dark corner, the “uninvolved” observer. But not always. “h” has his sensitivity, have his intimate, personal moments as well. One of them is “Invisible Ink” – once again, a song which could been placed easily on “Clutching at Straws” as well.
The down side are the kind of “easy”, settled, almost Pop taste of “Pour My Love” type of songs which – for me at least – making no sense. “Lucky Man” have a little bit better taste, at least have more life in it. Not so sure about the title track as well, but love its sound and tension. The closing “The Sky Above the Rain” with its over 10 minutes it’s a gentle, sensible panorama build upon a quiet piano them, Hogarth’s voice, some blue flavored strings and served with some tasty guitar interventions. Maybe too classy, maybe even Romantic, but nice.
Marillion are the last ones of a dying breed? Eventually. But while bands such as Yes or Genesis are stuck in their own past, Marillion breathing their present and still looking into the future. Their future. Not completely like their choices and not always support them unconditionally, but respect their effort of staying themselves against all the so-called expectations, against the trends and against the fake conservatorism.
This is not “that” Marillion, this is definitively “something” else, although if you dig deeper, dive under the surface of the sound, many things stay the same, but well, we’re in 2012, not in 1982 anymore! Get over it, and do yourself a favor: listen this detached.


01 – Gaza
02 – Sounds That Can’t Be Made
03 – Pour My Love
04 – Power
05 – Montr©al
06 – Invisible Ink
07 – Lucky Man
08 – The Sky Above the Rain

Marillion – Official Site
Marillion @ MySpace
Marillion @ Twitter

9 comments on “Marillion – Sounds That Can’t Be Made (2012)

  1. I am still waiting for that Fish… to return – to make sounds they could make but they cannot anymore.. You wonder how they would have sounded with Fish … somehow I am great believer they would have sounded better…

    • I can hear you! As they admitted: it would be better for them if they should changed the name of the band and started this from scratches back in 1989.
      Fish stayed pretty the same, but somehow he also suffering from the lack of the contribution of his old buddies…
      So, no such thing as “win – win” situation, isn’t it?

  2. Listen to the last few Fish releases and then ask if you want Marillion to go in that direction. He did 4 albums with Marillion. H has done 13, the history of the band belongs more to him. Look, I absolutely love the first four albums, but Fish made his choice and that was 25+ years ago. We have to move sometime. The Fish that was in Marillion doesn’t exist anymore

    • I think I lost tracking Fish around “Fellini Days”…. that was around 2000 I guess….. 😆
      “Raingods with Zippos” was a nice one, by the way.
      We’re all getting older and we’re lost our edge… That’s a fact.

  3. I’ll give a listen to the album sometime. I haven’t been fully convinced by a Marillion album since Brave but they occasionally had a few good moments. Their 2-3 last albums sounded much too quiet, with mostly boring ballads, and I had almost given up hope that they’d ever wake up. But this Gaza song sounds very promising as they seem to have injected some energy into their music again.
    I love the artwork, by the way. The shell-like 3D structure reminds me of comic artist Andreas (Cromwell Stone).

    • “Gaza” sounds interesting in deed. And generally, “Sounds That Can’t Be Made” it’s one of the best post-Fish Marillion’s album.

  4. Totally missed this album and I’ll be going to my Spotify later tonight for it. But I have to admit (to myself) that I’ll probably will be hard pressed to ignore the Fish era albums. How can I not be “tainted” by Fugazi?!!


      • Nope, not the Marillion of my old vinyls… Something completely different and I agree with your ending sentence BV; “listen this detached.” I’m not saying it’s not good on its own but… Fish-purists beware!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *